26 Comments
User's avatar
Liz LaSorte's avatar

This is such an important discussion.

One of the first things we can do is stop being afraid that people call us names, like Islamophobe:

https://lizlasorte.substack.com/p/stop-calling-us-islamophobes?r=76q58

Brian M's avatar

I could care less being called a racist, bigot or "Islamaphobe". I call as I see it. I do have Muslim friends who are fairly secular and who respect my religion. There is no effort to convert me or threaten me. But the "Islamists", so we can draw a distinction, are a different story. Anyone who insists in forcibly following Sharia Law is an Islamist. When they say: but Jews have rabbis who are the legal authorities, the comeback is: that is cultural law only, like marriage or divorce. It does not include civil or criminal law in America (acknowledging that 150 years ago in Russia rabbis did practice civil law). Islamists are dedicated to upholding Quranic commands to "kill the Infidel" if they cannot be converted. In the Haddath, the writings of Muhammed is this: "The tradition states that the final hour will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, and stones or trees will call out; "O Muslim, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him."

Unwoke in Idaho's avatar

I usually don't listen to podcasts but I did listen to this one today. I found it fascinating. Inserting the biblical discussion on the Promised Land and the Chosen People was something I'd heard before but not in that depth. Well done.

PS My husband would agree 100% with the thought that anyone holding elective office in the US should be native born and NOT an immigrant. He actually brought that up the other day. Sadly that would not disqualify the repellant Abdulrahman Mohammed El-Sayed but perhaps the dual citizenship would. It would send the Zohran and his artist chattel packing however.

234's avatar

It would disqualify Ilan Omar.......a healthy start.

Richard's avatar

Lot in there but it is sort of confused. There is a large body of Christian just war theory. The founding thinker was St. Augustine though he was drawing on a large body of pre-Christian thinkers. Then the theory was elaborated by St. Thomas Aquinas. These two established the core of the theory which is still influential. I am no Biblical scholar but those who are tend to agree that "Though shall not kill" is a mistranslation of "Thou shall not murder" from the Jewish tradition. The mistranslation is in the King James Bible which tends to be the one cited in the Anglosphere. Given that the Stuarts were all around bad actors, perhaps the mistranslation was deliberate. But anyway kill and murder are different concepts. In just war theory, absolutely anything the Israelis could have done in response to October 7, including nukes, would have been justified. The standard is not body counts but in what is necessary to accomplish a just goal. The just goal was to keep Hamas from continuing their terrorism and to keep Iran from funding and arming them. So far, this goal has yet to be accomplished so perhaps a different approach might be better tactically. But anything would be justified under Christian theory. Christians saying otherwise are just channeling ancient hatred of Jews.

Brian M's avatar

Not just "Christian Theory", but just about any Human theory. It is international law that a country is allowed to strike back violently against another country which kills first. That is what established the right of America to enter the 2nd World War, after Pearl Harbor. Until America was struck, it was iffy, though America had lost transports across the Atlantic to German subs. It might be theologically possible that Buddhists and Hindus would refuse to strike back. But, in practicality, China is mostly Buddhist and it would defend itself. India is mostly Hindu and has in fact defended itself. Japan and most of south Asia are also Buddhist and there has been plenty of warfare in that sphere. I think retaliatory war does not require a very difficult religious argument.

Richard's avatar

And in some cases, preemptive war can be justified. Self defense law has a lot of similarities to just war theory and was probably derived from it. You are not required to let the attacker fire the first shot.

Brian M's avatar

Yes, "imminent threat" (such as a threatened nuclear attack). Would suffice. It would be defensive in nature. There is no justification for engaging in an offensive campaign to expand territory, like Russia has done. One issue many Americans do not understand or acknowledge is that Iran and the Ayatollah declared war on America in 1979 when it took over the American Embassy, which by international law is sovereign American territory. Just the taking was an act of war. That war has never ended. There has never been a treaty or armistice that ends that war. Trump is carrying out a campaign to finally end a 47 year war on America's terms. It is just according to international law

Richard's avatar

I think both Ukraine and Russia have a valid just war position. The bad actor here is NATO which has both threatened Russia and egged Ukraine on. Ukraine's position about Russia is pretty obvious. For Russia's position, you have to look at history and the beginning point is important. Barring Iceland, every NATO country has invaded Russia and the attack on Serbia which threatened no NATO country marked a transition of NATO from a defensive alliance to an offensive one. This was not widely noticed in the West but I can guarantee that Russia noticed.

Brian M's avatar

Here is an AI generated summary of acceptable reasons for war:

Modern International Law and the Prohibition

Today, these historical justifications are entirely rejected under modern international law.

• The UN Charter: Article 2(4) of the United Nations Charter strictly prohibits the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state.

• Illegal Aggression: The International Criminal Court (ICC) classifies launching an offensive war as a crime of aggression.

• No Legal Title: Under modern legal norms (specifically the Ex injuria jus non oritur principle), a state cannot gain legal title to territory or resources through illegal force. Resource extraction following an illegal invasion is classified as pillage or plundering, which are recognized as war crimes.

The only globally recognized legal justifications for war today are self-defense (under Article 51 of the UN Charter) or military action authorized by the UN Security Council to maintain international peace and security.

Richard's avatar

The UN is explicitly not a Christian organization and is downright hostile to Jews. The ICC is more or less demonic. My comment was directed towards Sasha's discussion about Christianity. Neither are relevant to Judeo-Christians.

The notion that borders can't be changed by force is ridiculous. Couldn't find one for the Middle East but here is one for Europe. Warning, do not click if you have epilepsy.

https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1i1e6h

Judy Ogden's avatar

Sasha, Jerm distilled the Truth of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, the one true Jewish Messiah and one and only Son of God Who willingly came, lived, suffered, and as you are beginning to grasp, willingly GAVE His own life to save us all (both Jews and Gentiles) from our own sinful choices which necessitate complete (and eternal) separation from our Creator who is Holy, Perfect, Righteous, and Just. Without the covering of His blood over our sins—only possible through His WILLING Sacrificial Death—we would be without hope. But Hallelujah, JESUS IS OUR HOPE…and the Bible from Genesis to Revelation is all about Him!✝️🙌

And I, along with fellow followers of Christ (the Greek translation of the Hebrew word for Messiah, btw) am amazed—and often moved to tears—each time I truly contemplate the Greatest Love that can ever be known made manifest by Jesus Himself as He revealed the very Heart of God—and of Himself as equal personage in the Trinity: Father, Son, and Holy

Spirit—to all who will believe.

Keep seeking, Sasha! And Jerm, thank you for so openly and honestly sharing the simple truths of Biblical history, and most importantly of the Gospel, without pretense. May God honor and bless you both and your work!🙏✝️❤️

pjb535i's avatar

Sasha —

Great podcast!

A few observations:

I was struck by a recurring theme by both of you during your discussion that I will characterize as “I hope you don’t think I’m Islamophobic!”. We’ve been so conditioned to ignore our lying eyes and ears vis-à-vis Islam that we feel compelled to apologize for calling a spade a spade.

Fact:

There are moderate Muslims, but there IS NO moderate Islam.

Americans need to realize and accept this truth.

I loved how your host characterized the importance of the cross for Christianity and for all mankind. And how you responded 💚.

It was the Jewish religious ruling class that conspired with the Roman government to kill Jesus. Is it any surprise that the Jewish ruling class at that time was corrupt? Is it any surprise that ANY ruling class at ANY time in history is corrupt? It’s virtually a given that they will be. Just look around (ahem, RINOs).

Lastly, as a Christian, I too am a huge Ben Shapiro fan. Great call to listen to his podcast re the history of Israel. I need to go find that one and give it a listen (or two).

Pamela Eubank's avatar

The podcast was excellent!

Kenn Goodwin's avatar

Love it when they hate you and your words.

Brian M's avatar

Sasha, it is a long podcast. Would you mind running it through Chat GPT and distilling a 1000 word or less summary?

Margaret G's avatar

Sasha, this was an interesting discussion but I would take issue with your description of it as the "history of Christianity, Islam and Judaism". There were small snippets in there of how both Islam and Judaism came about (from Abraham's sons Ishmael and Isaac, etc.) but Jerm frequently pointed out that he is not a historian, and although you suggested he include a link to Ben Shapiro's video about the history of the region now known as Israel, he didn't post the link. Ben probably knows a lot more about it from the Jewish perspective. Jerm is clearly a devout Christian and so his perspective on Christianity and the involvement of Jews in Jesus' death was entirely based on what is written in the Bible, but there are many different ways to look at this. I just finished reading the book The Birth of Christianity" by John Dominic Crossan, which is 600+ pages of very dense, thoroughly referenced, scholarly analysis of the history of Palestine during Roman times and how people lived then and what they understood about their Jewish faith as it was impacted by Roman rule. I think it is important to study such works rather than rely on what was written about Jesus after he died (Jesus himself never wrote anything down). There is a big difference between what the original Jesus followers understood and what was written later, largely influenced by St. Paul (who never met Jesus in person and disagreed with those who were closest to Jesus, such as his brother James). I personally think people should be free to believe whatever they like about their God as long as they don't go around massacring those whom they disagree with, or forcing their beliefs on others. But please study the history of Christianity in the context of Roman rule (and yes, the Romans, not the Jews, killed Jesus). Another important work is Tom Holland's 2019 book "Dominion" which goes into enormous detail about how Christianity became the dominant world religion. Very detailed and very insightful, again written by a historian with deep knowledge about the Romans and Greeks and the influences on world history starting from those times. We shouldn't be taking wild stabs at what was going on at the time when religions were influencing world events without understanding the real history, not just the perspective of religious scholars. Just my 2 cents! Thanks for all you do, Sasha.

Smacko9's avatar

from:

https://truthjihad.com/2026/10/01/ffwn-plumber-saves-flyziodubai-flight-and-netanyahu-with-j-michael-springmann/

--------

10/7 Truth Movement

11) Netanyahu Received an Explicit Warning Days Before Oct. 7. He Didn’t Brief Israel’s Security Chiefs https://archive.ph/dpuc8

12) Netanyahu scurried to Dubai to ask UAE to deny October 7 warning claim https://www.rt.com/news/646357-netanyahu-hamas-attack-warnings/

13) Don’t write off Netanyahu over Oct. 7 warning claims – Trump https://www.rt.com/news/646635-trump-netanyahu-uae-warning/

14) Qatar’s prime minister said Hamas agreed on the first day of the war on Gaza to “release all civilian hostages,” asking only for a ceasefire window to get them out, and Israel refused to even “entertain the idea.” https://x.com/DropSiteNews/status/2105049212148695243?s=20

15) Did Netanyahu Know about the October 7 Attack BEFORE It Happened? Egypt and UAE Warned Him Multiple Times https://needtoknow.news/2026/10/did-netanyahu-know-october-7-attack-before-it-happened-egypt-and-uae-reportedly-warned-him-multiple-times/

234's avatar

I'm quite sure if you navigated through the vast emptiness of the internet, within a few minutes you could find research that the earth is flat, and man never walked on the moon.

Smacko9's avatar

“Oct 7 anniversary crashout - Max live on Judging Freedom.” The Grayzone

https://teeashby.substack.com/p/oct-7-anniversary-crashout-max-live

Oct8'26

Smacko9's avatar

Haaretz: Netanyahu Was Warned 10 Days Before October 7, 2023 Attack

Israeli newspaper presents evidence of what many observers have long suspected to be the case.

John Leake Sep10'26

https://www.thefocalpoints.com/p/haaretz-netanyahu-was-warned-10-days

Smacko9's avatar

Hoaxes “R” Us: Flydubai and the Russian Plague

Stop them before they hoax again

https://donaldjeffries.substack.com/p/hoaxes-r-us-flydubai-and-the-russian

Oct7'26