Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jim Trageser's avatar

Butker only got it half-right: Men, too, have been lied to about careers being more important than family. Being a father and husband is just as important and fulfilling as being a mom; a career is no more than the way we provide for our families in a modern society. In many ways, Western society is still dealing with the urbanization that accompanied the Industrial Revolution. In an agrarian society, the man and woman were true partners in providing for their children. Yes, in most families, the man did much of the heavier work - ploughing, harvesting, etc. But we know there were families in which the wife was stronger, and did much of the outdoor work. But preserving food, tanning hides to make leather to make clothes, spinning wool and cotton into thread, weaving that into fabric to make clothes. Between them, the man and woman had to provide EVERYTHING for their family.

As we moved off farms and into cities, there weren't hides to tan, wool to card, crops to preserve. As schools became available, and then mandatory, for working and lower class families, there weren't even children to supervise during much of the day.

So the old model no longer applies - but it's important to remember that in the old social order, men weren't the "providers" - husbands and wives together provided, with children pitching in from an early age.

As we continue working out new models for sustaining families, it's important to keep reminding ourselves that the raising of children is the only real purpose of any society - for both men and women.

Expand full comment
Brandy's avatar

Because I chose the path of housewife and mother, I truly appreciated what he said. Many times, women who choose to stay home are belittled by other women. I decided I had 100% to give. I could give it to my family or a career, but I don't have 200%, so one or the other or both would suffer. That is just a choice I made. And, I'm grateful to the women who came before that allowed me to make that choice. Another commenter made a good point about being left by a man with no marketable skills. I agree this is a danger. What I would advise in that situation (or what I did) was get my degree - mostly online, some in-person just in case. It gave me security. I just didn't have to use it. Or, I haven't had to use it yet and the kids are grown.

Expand full comment
62 more comments...

No posts